Mets & Reds

Submitted by: samberg

Mets

NameAgeLevelP1P2AvailabilityYearsAFVSalarySurplusLowMedianHigh
Luis Castillo29MajorsSPHigh1.455.314.141.232.941.249.4
Brandon Drury29Majors2B3BMedium0.46.30.464.867.2
Mike Moustakas33Majors2B3BHigh1.4128.6-27.6-33.2-27.6-22.1

Total Value:

19.6

Reds

NameAgeLevelP1P2AvailabilityYearsAFVSalarySurplusLowMedianHigh
Jose ButtoMinorsRHP2.21.82.22.6
Nick PlummerMinorsOF1.10.81.11.4
Junior SantosMinorsRHP1.91.51.92.3
Mike VasilMinorsRHP10.811.2
Mark VientosMinors3B14.411.514.417.3

Total Value:

20.6

Challenger

I don't find Ziegler in the Mets' 40-man or top-30 prospect list.

General Manager Badge
johnbitzer

You just need to look at the right lists: https://blogs.fangraphs.com/new-york-mets-top-30-prospects-2022/ https://www.baseballamerica.com/teams/1013/new-york-mets/organizational/

Challenger

I have to comment on this proposed trade because I keep seeing this happen. The most foolish thing the Reds FO could do would be to include a negative point value player (especially Moustakis) in a trade for Luis Castillo. This only diminishes his value and the return from trade partners. I know there are those in Red land who believe the Reds FO is only trying to reduce payroll and fail to embrace a restructure that will increase the Redlegs chances of actually winning a world series. If the Rewds FO actually made this trade, these doubters would have evidence of that. .

samberg

I agree it's not a smart trade from the Red's perspective, and I probably didn't provide enough value coming from the Mets. I think a legit guy like Ziegler would make it more realistic

NEWSLETTER? SURE, SIGN ME UP!