Mariners & Rays

Submitted by: mp2891

Mariners

NameAgeLevelP1P2AvailabilityYearsAFVSalarySurplusLowMedianHigh
Isaac Paredes25Majors3BLow3.477.327.350405060

Total Value:

50

Rays

NameAgeLevelP1P2AvailabilityYearsAFVSalarySurplusLowMedianHigh
Matt Brash26MajorsRPLow4.440.821.619.215.419.223
Harry Ford21MinorsC00021.417.121.425.7
Tai Peete18MinorsSS3B0006.45.16.47.7
Aidan Smith20MinorsOF0002.522.53

Total Value:

49.5

General Manager Badge
mp2891

If the Rays trade Paredes, the Mariners remain my preferred trade partner because their system aligns with the Rays' needs so well. Rays have a huge need for a top catching prospect, which Ford would fill. They lack top outfield prospects, which Smith would help remedy. Teams can always use pitchers with elite stuff, and while there is a risk that Brash doesn't come back strong, it's a reasonable risk/reward to take given his current trade value. Last but not least is Peete, who the Rays were said to covet in last year's draft and who plays a position that is very much a weakness on the Rays' current active roster. Rays can't add enough SS to the Farm in my opinion. From the Mariners standpoint, they need a big consistent bat, which Paredes provides. They also need someone with a reasonable salary and ideally controlled beyond 2024. Paredes checks all of those boxes. Some will look under the Paredes' hood and complain about his hard hit rates and exit velocities (and some will even talk about it being harder to hit well in Seattle than it is in the Rays' dome). I'll just say this - Paredes has performed around a 4 WAR pace each year he's been a Ray and while he plays better at home (147 wRC+) than away (128 wRC+), his bat would become the best bat in Seattle's 2024 lineup even if he just hits at his away split.

General Manager Badge
ShaquilleOatmeal

We're on the same page. Although the Rays would have to really be sold that Ford is a future building block. There's just so few good catchers in the game. Every year, what are there like 5 or so that are 3 WAR? So many more options if you try to get those wins from elsewhere. But I want Ford too. The black hole behind home plate was so nice to have filled by Zunino...for one year. I like it. Make the trade (and Seattle should be all over this. If they blow a 8 game lead to the Astros and miss the playoffs, they can all kiss their jobs goodbye).

NEWSLETTER? SURE, SIGN ME UP!